JINYAN LAW FIRM

 Cases

Cases

Jin Yan's Case | Ceremony held, registration not carried out - Legal dilemmas and solutions for disputes over marital property and property division during cohabitation

Author:admin date: 2026-07-10 read:186
Summary:

Case Details

Wang Mou and Zheng Mou (the female party) established a romantic relationship through a mutual acquaintance in the spring of 2019. They got to know each other and their feelings gradually intensified. In November 2021, they officially held a wedding ceremony, with relatives and friends gathering together to celebrate the marriage. 

However, behind the lively celebration lay hidden concerns - after the ceremony, the two parties never went to the civil affairs bureau to register their marriage. In this seemingly ambiguous status, the conflicts between them gradually accumulated and eventually led to a parting of ways.

Wang Mou then filed a lawsuit in court, demanding that Zheng Mou return the betrothal gifts and divide the property purchased during their cohabitation, such as houses, furniture, and appliances. In response to this situation, Zheng Mou entrusted lawyer Wu Ziwen from Jinyan Law Firm to defend her rights legally. A legal battle over betrothal gifts, property, and joint property thus began.

Case Analysis

After accepting the case, lawyer Wu Ziwen from Jinyan Law Firm comprehensively analyzed the complexity of this case. On the surface, the case was classified as a "betrothal property dispute", but in reality, it also involved a "dispute over the division of cohabitation property". The two case types intertwined and overlapped, with as many as three core issues of contention: (1) Which money should be considered "betrothal gifts"? In this case, the plaintiff Wang Mou included the money for getting off the carriage during the wedding ceremony, wedding banquet expenses, and master of ceremonies fees in the scope of betrothal gifts and claimed a return; (2) Which things purchased during cohabitation belong to whom? During their cohabitation, the two parties jointly purchased furniture, appliances, and renovated the residence. How should these properties be divided was the second major issue of contention in this case; (3) Dispute over property depreciation loss: Who should bear the market risk? The most complex point of contention in this case was the ownership of the property involved and the assumption of depreciation loss. It was found that the property involved was jointly purchased by both parties during their cohabitation and should be recognized as jointly owned by both parties. However, due to fluctuations in the real estate market, the property depreciated to a certain extent during the period from purchase to the lawsuit, resulting in substantial economic losses. The plaintiff claimed that all the losses should be borne by the defendant, which was clearly unfair.

Lawyer Wu Ziwen argued rationally, citing the principle of joint ownership, claiming that the depreciation loss of the property should be jointly borne by both parties according to their contribution ratio or the principle of joint ownership, and that the market risk should not be single-handedly transferred to the female party. Lawyer Wu Ziwen established a clear representation strategy and conducted precise defense from five dimensions:

(1) Clarify the reason for not registering. In the plaintiff's complaint, it was stated that the relationship broke down due to the defendant's unwillingness to register for marriage. The attorney collected WeChat chat records, witness testimony, etc. to restore the truth - it was the plaintiff's side that was unwilling to promptly register for marriage, not the defendant Zheng Mou. This effectively refuted the plaintiff's false statement.

(2) Define the boundary of betrothal gifts. Strictly distinguish between betrothal gifts and ordinary consumption expenses. Exclude the money for getting off the carriage, wedding banquet expenses, etc. from the scope of betrothal gifts, and prove that the paid betrothal gifts were used to purchase dowries and for common life, effectively squeezing out the plaintiff's claim space.

(3) Clearly prove property joint ownership. With the supporting evidence of contribution certificates and proof of common life, it was proved that the furniture, appliances, and decoration expenses purchased during cohabitation were jointly contributed by both parties, and it was claimed to be shared equally, preventing the plaintiff from seizing all movable property alone.

(4) Reasonably share losses. Uphold the principle of joint ownership and claim that the depreciation loss of the property should be shared by both parties in proportion, protecting the defendant's property rights.

(5) Suggest combined trial. Given that this case involved both a "betrothal property dispute" and a "dispute over the division of cohabitation property" as two case types, lawyer Wu Ziwen actively suggested that the court conduct a combined trial to resolve all disputes at once, avoiding repeated litigation and increasing litigation burden for the parties.

Case Significance Jin Yan lawyer Wu Ziwen, after completing the court trial preparations in an orderly manner and fully presenting the legal opinions, actively cooperated with the court in conducting the mediation work. He actively communicated and negotiated with the opposing party and their agents regarding the core disputed points such as the return of betrothal gifts, property division, and liability for property losses from the house. He meticulously interpreted the relevant legal provisions and proposed a fair and reasonable mediation plan based on the specific case circumstances.

After multiple rounds of negotiations, both parties finally reached an agreement under the auspices of the court: Defendant Zheng agreed to return 90,000 yuan to the plaintiff. Both parties reached an agreement on the matters related to the betrothal property and the division of the cohabitation relationship. The case was successfully concluded. This mediation result not only protected the legitimate rights and interests of the client Zheng, avoided him from suffering unfair property losses, but also enabled both parties to be relieved from the long-lasting disputes, achieving the unity of legal effect and social effect.

Behind "the ceremony has been held but the registration has not been carried out" lies the potential legal risks that countless families may face. Marriage is a major event in life, and law is a solid backing for safeguarding rights. Jin Yan Law Firm has always adhered to the service concept of professionalism and responsibility, protecting the legitimate rights and interests of every client through the law, and safeguarding the legal rights and interests of every family. If you encounter confusion in family law areas such as betrothal property, division of cohabitation property, and divorce property division, please contact us. Jin Yan Law Firm is willing to provide you with professional legal support.

Lawyer Introduction

news_2020jinyan20260104160428auug2.jpg

Wu Ziwen, a lawyer of Jinyan Law Firm, graduated from the Law Department of Henan Polytechnic University.

He is proficient in litigation services such as marital and family affairs, traffic accident damage compensation, loan disputes, criminal defense, as well as non-litigation legal services. With rich professional experience.

Contact Information:

Telephone: 18317297204

Email: 1176979568@qq.com