TEL: 0391-3581232
Case Introduction
The plaintiff, Zhang Mou, and her deceased husband, Xue Mou, had five children: Xue 1, Xue 2, Xue 3, Xue 4, and Xue 5. All the children were adults and lived independently. The plaintiff was elderly, had lost her ability to work, and was unable to take care of herself. After multiple attempts to negotiate with Xue 1, Xue 2, and Xue 3 regarding the issue of alimony without success, she filed a lawsuit in court.
The plaintiff's initial claim was: to order the three defendants to pay 54,000 yuan in alimony from January 1, 2016 to December 31, 2024; starting from January 1, 2025, each of the three defendants should pay 500 yuan per month until the plaintiff's death.
During the court trial, with the mediation of the court, all parties voluntarily reached an agreement: starting from March 1, 2025, Xue 1, Xue 2, Xue 3, Xue 4, and Xue 5 should each transfer 150 yuan to the plaintiff's Bank of China account before the 27th of each month; the remaining part of the medical expenses for the plaintiff's hospitalization after insurance reimbursement should be borne by each of the five children in equal shares; the case filing fee was reduced to 50 yuan, and each defendant should bear 10 yuan.
Case Review and Result
In this relatively small amount of alimony dispute case, there are many legal issues as follows:
(1) The Legality and Universality of the Alimony Obligation
The alimony obligation of adult children to their parents is a legal obligation that cannot be waived due to the parents' economic situation, the children's family difficulties, etc. In this case, the plaintiff was elderly, had lost her ability to work, and was unable to take care of herself, which met the legal circumstances of needing children's alimony. All five adult children had an unshirkable alimony obligation. Defendant Xue 3 claimed to reduce the alimony obligation due to his family's economic difficulties and needing to take care of relatives, although he could not oppose the legal alimony responsibility, but because the plaintiff had pensions and properties, the children should bear a reasonable alimony.
(2) The Rationality of the Alimony Obligation Party
The plaintiff initially only sued three children to bear the alimony responsibility, which did not conform to the principle of fairness. The alimony obligation should be jointly borne by all adult children, and only requiring some children to bear it would increase the burden on the sued children. The court finally added the other two children as co-defendants, and the final mediation agreement determined that all five children should jointly bear the alimony obligation, which balanced the rights and obligations and conformed to the legal principle of fairness.
(3) The Rationality of the Alimony Fee Standard
The plaintiff initially claimed 500 yuan per month in alimony, and the defendants considered the standard too high. The alimony fee amount should be determined based on the actual needs of the supported person, the local economic level, and the economic capacity of the alimony payer. After the mediation, it was determined that 150 yuan per month in alimony was paid, which not only guaranteed the plaintiff's basic living needs but also took into account the economic burden capacity of each child. The standard was more reasonable and feasible.
(4) The Issue of the Expiration of the Alimony Claim Time Limit
The defendants claimed that the plaintiff's claim for alimony from 2016 to 2021 had exceeded the statute of limitations. Eventually, the plaintiff voluntarily gave up this claim in the mediation, which was a legal exercise of her rights, and the court approved it, in line with the principle of civil litigation disposition.
(5) The Allocation Agreement of Medical Expenses
The mediation agreement stipulated that the remaining part of the medical expenses for the plaintiff's hospitalization after insurance reimbursement should be equally borne by the five children. This agreement fully guaranteed the plaintiff's life in old age and medical rights.
Case Summary
Although the family relationship between the plaintiff and the defendants was not harmonious, there was still a strong bond between them, and there was no deep hatred between the children and their mother. Lawyer Tang Meili, as the agent, actively cooperated with the judge to coordinate the defendant and the plaintiff to reach an on-the-spot settlement. Although it took a lot of time and there were intense arguments, the judge finally resolved the misunderstandings between both parties and restored the mother-son relationship. Although lawyers possess professional legal knowledge, when dealing with family disputes, they cannot simply apply the law mechanically. Instead, they need to empathize with the plaintiff and defendant emotionally, deeply understand the root causes of the conflicts among all parties, and strive to resolve the disputes, restore the damaged family relationships and亲情, and promote social harmony!
Lawyer Introduction

Tang Meili, a member of the Communist Party of China, is a practicing lawyer at Jinyan Law Firm. She graduated from North Minzu University and obtained her lawyer's license in 2015.
She specializes in commercial and economic cases such as private lending disputes, housing purchase contract disputes, construction contract disputes, as well as real estate and corporate affairs.
Contact Information:
Telephone: 18039133311
Email: 1075433424@qq.com