TEL: 0391-3581232
Case Introduction
Many parties believe that having the loan note in hand guarantees a victory. However, in cases of private lending disputes, "holding the loan note" never equates to "the establishment of creditor's rights". The case shared today was handled by Lawyer Wu Shengli of Jin Yan Law Firm for the defendant. After going through a first-instance loss, a complete reversal in the second-instance trial, and a re-examination ruling to reject the application for retrial, the entire process was reversed, helping the client avoid all repayment responsibilities.
This is a typical case of a settlement dispute in private lending. Our client (hereinafter referred to as "Mr. A") had a partnership and financial transactions with the other party (hereinafter referred to as "Ms. B") in the past. On October 6, 2017, the two parties settled and confirmed that Mr. A owed Ms. B 570,000 yuan without specifying an interest rate. Mr. A provided Ms. B with a loan note. Later, Mr. A made repayments of 35,000 yuan. On January 1, 2019, Ms. B asked Mr. A to issue another loan note: the principal was 535,000 yuan, with an interest rate of 1%. Ms. B knew that Mr. A had a large amount of external debt and was worried that he would not repay the money. In December 2022, the two parties reached an agreement to settle the case in one lump sum: Ms. B waived some of the interest, and Mr. A only needed to pay an additional 200,000 yuan to settle the loan principal and interest, and the creditor-debtor relationship would be completely eliminated. On January 28, 2023, Mr. A asked his ex-wife to help transfer 200,000 yuan to Ms. B. After receiving the money, Ms. B wrote "This note is settled" on the original 2017 loan note and signed it. The ex-wife of Mr. A retrieved it. However, later, Ms. B sued with the 2019 loan note, claiming that the loan was not yet repaid and demanding that Mr. A continue to repay the remaining principal and interest.
Trial Situation
First Instance: Loss under Formal Review
In the first instance, the court mainly accepted the fact that "the plaintiff held the original loan note", and did not adopt our defense. The first-instance judgment: Mr. A still needed to repay the remaining principal and interest.
Second Instance: Reconstructing the defense logic to achieve a reversal
After the first-instance loss, Lawyer Wu Shengli of Jin Yan Law Firm immediately reviewed the loopholes in the first instance and identified three core breakthrough points:
1. Fixed the true consensus of "one-time settlement". Actively helped the client obtain mobile phone evidence, allowing the client to find a replaced and unused mobile phone, sort out WeChat chat records and transfer timelines, proving the complete chain of prior negotiation, confirmation in the middle, and subsequent performance, confirming that 200,000 yuan was the settlement amount and not a partial repayment.
2. Precisely explain "This note is settled". Lawyer Wu Shengli of Jin Yan Law Firm argued from three levels: In terms of meaning: "settled" in the ordinary public understanding means "debt settlement"; In terms of common sense: The 2017 loan note had already been replaced by the 2019 loan note, and it could have been marked without any special annotation. Writing "This note is settled" is obviously a confirmation of "the debt has been settled"; In terms of evidence: The witness (the person who transferred the funds on behalf) testified in court that this annotation indicated that the debt was settled after receiving the payment.
3. Use data to prove. The total repayment amount exceeded the principal, and the claim of oral reduction of interest was reasonable and reasonable. The debt had already been fulfilled. The second-instance judgment: Reversed the first instance and ruled to dismiss all the plaintiff's litigation requests.
Re-examination: Stabilizing the effective judgment and guarding the victory outcome
Ms. B appealed to the provincial high court, claiming that the "fact determination in the second instance was incorrect". Lawyer Wu Shengli in the re-examination focused on three points: The settlement agreement between the two parties was truly valid; "This note is settled" was a clear expression of intention; The plaintiff's receiving the payment and then filing a lawsuit violated the principle of good faith. The re-examination ruling: Rejected the re-examination application and upheld the second-instance judgment. Thus, the case went through the entire process from first-instance loss, to second-instance reversal, and to re-examination maintenance, with the entire case being final and the client not having to repay a single penny.
Case Summary
This case underwent the entire process of first-instance, second-instance, and re-examination trials. The judgment result achieved a significant reversal, deeply confirming the judicial principles of civil litigation centered on evidence, based on facts, and adhering to integrity. Private lending settlement disputes are highly concealed and have complex case circumstances. A single written document often cannot restore the true transaction sequence. During the case handling process, Jin Yan's lawyer broke away from the fixed mindset of relying solely on documentary evidence, anticipated the potential risks of the case in advance, deeply analyzed the essence of the transaction, meticulously refined the evidence chain, adhered to the principle of substantive fairness, and firmly established the foundation for winning the case.
This case vividly demonstrated the professional litigation value of Jin Yan's lawyer. Professional lawyers are not only the agents for the rights protection of the clients, but also an important force in assisting in judicial corrections. Facing an unfavorable judgment in the first instance, Jin Yan's lawyer, relying on solid professional judgment capabilities, reviewed the entire case, sorted out logical flaws, accurately identified the flaws in the original judgment, and through rigorous defense strategies, achieved a reversal of the case in the subsequent trial. With professional legal capabilities, they restored objective facts, corrected judicial recognition deviations, and comprehensively safeguarded the legitimate rights and interests of the clients, adhering to the bottom line of legal fairness and justice.
At the same time, this case also fully demonstrated the core value of Jin Yan's lawyer's practice. Even when the case fell into a disadvantageous situation in the first instance, the lawyer still relied on professional legal thinking to sort out evidence, analyze legal principles, accurately identify judicial problems, and through professional defense to correct judicial deviations. Jin Yan's lawyer is not only a staunch defender of the legitimate rights and interests of the clients, but also an important professional force assisting the court in clarifying case facts and maintaining judicial justice.
Lawyer Introduction

Wu Shengli, a lawyer of Jinyan Law Firm.
With over 20 years of practice experience, specializing in criminal cases and civil and commercial cases. Has been awarded the title of "Outstanding Lawyer of Jiaozuo City".
Contact Information:
Telephone: 13938159795
Email: 1723654383@qq.com